id	summary	reporter	owner	description	type	status	priority	milestone	component	version	resolution	keywords	cc
6	Backquote  ,@,@ handling	gz	gb	"Given:

{{{
(defparameter *c* `((list :x 1) (list :y 2)))
}}}

reading

{{{
``(f ,@,@ *c*)
}}}


should return something that creates:


{{{
(f :x 1 :y 2)
}}}



OpenMCL's backquote generates:

{{{
(f (:x 1) : y 2)
}}}

Steele's reference backquote implementation (which is conditionalized
out in ""ccl:lib;backquote.lisp"") has other problems, but handles this
case as the user expects (and I tend to think that their expectation
is reasonable.)
"	defect	new	minor		ANSI CL Compliance	1.1			attila.lendvai@…